Fin O'Suilleabhain on
Les Exclusifs: Bel Respiro, No 18, & 28 La Pausa by Chanel {Perfume Review & Musings} {New Perfumes}
: Hi ... can I ask about the Stravinsky / Chanel image. Is ...
Thalestris Dupont on
Fragonard Caresse (1929/2008) {Perfume Review}
: Lovely perfume! Reminds me of the spring 2011 when I was wearing ...
Karen Lindsey on
Long Lost Crabtree & Evelyn Fragrance: Help Please {Ask The Readers}
: I just found this site and I so need to find someone ...
Regina on
Happy New Year 2012!
: Valentine's Day will soon be here. Any recommendations?
C Sasich on
Easy Tricks To Create Golden Globes Hairstyles! {Beauty Notes - Hair}
: My fave was Michelle Williams - modern , effortless not overdone . ...
kelvin neo on
Victoria's Secret Life is Pink Wish Pink, Live Pink, Hope Pink (2010) *New Fragrances*
: Hi good day, Can i know where can purchase or order Pink ...
Alan on
A Funny Post About Scented Candles {Fragrant Reading}
: Hell-scent candle, lol.
Gina on
Two Organic Oud Scents: Sama Oudh Jasmin & Undergreen Black Classic (2011) {New Perfumes}
: I want to try Sama Oudh Jasmin but checked the websites. I ...
Tammy on
Top 12 Best New Department Store Fragrances of 2011 for the Holidays {Perfume List}
: Wish this came with a little print out sheet for my next ...
Toñi on
Dance with Givenchy (2010) {New Perfume}
: Where can I get Dance with Givenchy? It's impossible to find it ...
Toñi on
Dance with Givenchy (2010) {New Perfume}
: Where can I get Dance with Givenchy? It's impossible to find it ...
evageli karounzou on
Choppy Waters for Stella Cadente Miss Me {Fragrance News}
: at 2007 i was in paris an i bought this perfume.Since then ...
Mandy Aftel on
Aftelier Perfumes Secret Garden (2011): Featuring Real Civet & Castoreum {New Fragrance}
: Thank you so much Marie-Helene for your lovely review! You are great ...
Kay on
Mona di Orio Chamarré (2009): Perfume Review in Memoriam
: This is very interesting. First thing that came to my mind when ...
Maddy on
Bint el Sudan, The Other, African Chanel No.5: Interview with Nick Evans of International Flavors & Fragrances, Inc. {Perfume Q & A - The Scents of Africa}
: Interesting post. I've lived in Ghana but I don't remember encountering anyone ...
Comments
H, thank you so much for these stills! I can't wait for the release of the film, as I loved the book and think Cyllian Murphy will be a good Grenouille. Still, I would have preferred an all-French crew - it's best to leave it up to the French to recreate 19th century France, don't you agree?
Posted by: Dusan | September 8, 2006
Dusan,
You're welcome! Maybe the French will do another one; that would be interesting, but not necessarily better IMO. And you meant to say in the 18th century I think.
Posted by: Mimi | September 8, 2006
Dustin Hoffman as Baldini...brilliant !
Cillian Murphy as Grenouille- WHAT were they thinking- maybe a reasonable actor, but WAY too pretty....P.U. !
Posted by: chayaruchama | September 8, 2006
Did I write 19th? Oops, I did mean the 18th century.
Posted by: Dusan | September 8, 2006
Just pointed it out in case other readers who don't know the story might get confused:)
Posted by: Mimi | September 8, 2006
Chaya,
I can't wait to see the movie! They have certainly prettied up Grenouille. He is supposed to be very ugly. I wonder who would have been a better cast regarding physical appearance?
Posted by: Mimi | September 8, 2006
Cillian (sp?) is far from ugly, but he does have that dark, hard, monomaniacal look in his eyes, very intense. I keep trying to cast someone Grenouille-ugly in my mind, but nothing comes. Vincent Cassel would fit physically (or is he too tall?) but he is overtly agressive, rather than being a contemplative, silent murderer. Jeremy Renier? Or that kid who played opposite Vanessa Paradis in that film where she's a hooker who has to take care of her "colleague's" son? I'm not usually terrible w/ names :-)
Posted by: Dusan | September 8, 2006
that's not Cillian Murphy - it's Ben Whishaw, who once played Keith Richards. http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0924210/
Posted by: houseofstone | September 8, 2006
Oh lordie, that IS Ben Whishaw, not CM! I cannot believe I was so stupid!
Posted by: Dusan | September 8, 2006
OK, folks-
NO ONE could do it better than Geoffrey Rush !
Posted by: chayaruchama | September 8, 2006
Chaya,
Geofrrey Rush is a genius, but isn't he a wee bit old for the part?
Posted by: Dusan | September 8, 2006
Chaya,
Geoffrey Rush is a genius, but isn't he a wee bit old for the part?
Posted by: Dusan | September 8, 2006
Mimi, a wonderful coup for you to have these pictures -- I posted on my natural perfumers group, so they shall all be visiting the SS and sniffing what you have to offer.
What wonderful stills from the movie, so evocative for the perfumer or lover of perfumes and their history.
Posted by: Anya | September 10, 2006
Anya,
I love the pictures too. I think that for a perfume aficionado they are just dreamy. Thanks for linking up to TSS!
Posted by: Mimi | September 11, 2006
The book was so very dark, I'm hoping that the movie can replicate the mood. Dustin Hoffman will draw the American audience with familiarity appeal, but Grenouille has to carry it, I would think. I'm glad that he's not as ugly as he is portrayed in the book. Having no personal scent is bad enough.
Posted by: Diane | September 13, 2006
The book was so very dark, I'm hoping that the movie can replicate the mood. Dustin Hoffman will draw the American audience with familiarity appeal, but Grenouille has to carry it, I would think. I'm glad that he's not as ugly as he is portrayed in the book. Having no personal scent is bad enough.
Posted by: Diane | September 13, 2006
I thought that if Johnny Depp went through a proper make over he would be my choice as a Grenouille. If anyone can play dark roles, and morph into any appearance (albeit his good looks in real life - did you see "The Libertine"?! - he gets quite greusome there ) that would be my pick. And what about his talent for accents?! He's also a Franchophile and lives most of the time in France.
What could be better?!
Actually before I found out that a movie was in the making I had always thought to myself how I wish Perfume were made into a film - because the part pf Grenouille was made for Depp.
Posted by: Ilana | November 12, 2006
I thought that if Johnny Depp went through a proper make over he would be my choice as a Grenouille. If anyone can play dark roles, and morph into any appearance (albeit his good looks in real life - did you see "The Libertine"?! - he gets quite greusome there ) that would be my pick. And what about his talent for accents?! He's also a Franchophile and lives most of the time in France.
What could be better?!
Actually before I found out that a movie was in the making I had always thought to myself how I wish Perfume were made into a film - because the part pf Grenouille was made for Depp.
Posted by: Ilana | November 12, 2006
Ilana,
You know I think that, that might actually work. I agree that Depp can bring a dark coloring to a movie although I also think that he is still a bit green and "clean" and could develop more depth in his roles. I saw part of The Libetine; there were moments when he was good and others when he didn't seem to be really embracing his role fully. Perhaps with a great director this could be improved.
The actor who played his servant in the movie was absolutely great on the other hand. Gosh, what's his name? He should be payed a better tribute than that:) Is it Jack Davenport?
In the novel, Grenouille is supposed to be ugly as sin and then later become disfigured by his illness. In as much as Depp could be disfigured for the role yet presumably retain his innate sexiness, that might make for an interesting character composition. From the perspective of the spectator that might be effective too. They made Grenouille so PC-looking for the movie, it's a shame.
Posted by: Marie-Hélène | November 12, 2006